ESG Zertifikate auf einem virtuellen Bildschirm, den eine Person hält

Real Estate ESG certificates in the building sector | an Overview

20.02.2024 4 Reading Time

In times of rising energy and construction costs, hardly any other sector is more in demand to scrutinise its actions. This change must and will manifest itself in the properties themselves.

In recent years and in view of global efforts to achieve an ecologically sustainable economy, the demands placed on properties have increased considerably. Optimising individual components is no longer enough these days. Rather, a sustainable property combines the lowest possible environmental impact, a high level of attractiveness for investors and tenants and taxonomy conformity with optimum risk management.

To prove compliance with these requirements, many asset managers and property owners make use of common certifications from independent providers. However, with the growing selection of providers, the question sometimes arises as to which certificate is the most meaningful? At Commerz Real, our Global Head of Asset Management and Sustainability Jens Böhnlein is an expert on certificates and knows their strengths and weaknesses. He makes his judgement from the perspective of an expert - after all, he has already worked as a BREEAM and LEED auditor.

A clear favourite: the DGNB certificate

Even if there is little excitement in the derivation, our clear favourite in terms of ESG certificates is that of the DGNB. Thanks to a holistic assessment approach, DGNB-certified buildings not only offer ecological benefits, but also contribute to improving quality of life and sustainable urban development. However, due to its complexity, the DGNB certificate initially faced difficulties in terms of implementation and acceptance on the market. Furthermore, when it was introduced, it was in direct competition with internationally established certification systems such as LEED and BREEAM.

With its holistic approach, it was initially able to establish itself in Germany and later also in Europe. The DGNB's endeavours to adapt the system to national characteristics and different building types, as well as to facilitate its applicability, have increasingly borne fruit.

EU taxonomy: adaptability is required

A key advantage of the DGNB certificate is its adaptability to the changing EU taxonomy requirements. The DGNB's assessment methodology is largely based on the principles of the EU taxonomy. The certification thus ensures transparency and comparability with regard to the sustainability performance of properties. At the same time, it emphasises its importance as an instrument for promoting sustainable construction and investment in line with European regulations.

Another advantage that sets the DGNB System apart from the competition: It can be used to apply for funding - also because it is accepted by the German government as a verification tool for obtaining the Quality Label for Sustainable Buildings (QNG) and the associated federal subsidy for energy-efficient buildings (BEG).

Beyond the borders of the EU

In order to export its certification system beyond Germany's borders, the DGNB has continuously adapted it to the specific conditions and requirements of other countries: For example, local climatic, cultural and legal conditions have been taken into account. In addition, the DGNB has established partnerships with various countries and strengthened its presence in Europe, Asia and other regions.

There are DGNB certifications and projects in countries such as Denmark, Austria, China and Brazil, to name but a few. The fact that many international construction projects have received or are seeking DGNB certification shows that international recognition is growing.

The top 3 at a glance

DGNB - the all-encompassing assessment tool

Launched in 2007 by the German Sustainable Building Council (DGNB) in Germany, the DGNB certificate is considered to be particularly comprehensive and one of the most advanced certification systems for sustainable architecture worldwide. Unlike BREEAM and LEED, it assesses buildings and neighbourhoods in their entirety, taking into account a wide range of sustainability aspects. The main categories are ecology, economy, socio-cultural and functional quality as well as technical, process and location quality.


Within these categories, various criteria such as energy efficiency, resource conservation, life cycle costs, comfort, health, integration into the social environment and ecological compatibility are assessed. Depending on the degree of fulfilment, the DGNB award is presented in bronze, silver or gold. Platinum certification is also possible for a particularly outstanding sustainability profile.

LEED - globally established and coveted

The environmental sustainability of buildings is also at the centre of the LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) assessment. Developed by the U.S. Green Building Council (USGBC) in the late 1990s, LEED is intended to help builders, architects, developers and owners to realise environmentally friendly and health-promoting buildings. LEED - similar to BREEAM - rates buildings based on a points system in various categories, such as energy efficiency, water conservation, CO2 emissions, improved interior quality, materials and resources, and innovation in design.

Depending on the number of points achieved, buildings can receive one of four certification levels: Certified, Silver, Gold and Platinum. The higher the level, the more sustainable the building is considered to be. LEED has developed into one of the world's leading certification systems and is used in over 160 countries. It serves as a benchmark for the design, construction, maintenance and operation of sustainable buildings, homes and communities and is considered to be extremely effective in terms of advertising.

BREEAM - the pioneer certificate

The "Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method", or BREEAM for short, was the first certificate to be launched in the UK in 1990.  Since then, it has become a triumphant success. It assesses properties in various sustainability categories, including energy efficiency, water use, health and well-being, pollution, transport, materials, waste, use and protection of the environment and management processes.

BREEAM is based on a points system and awards certificates at various levels: Pass, Good, Very Good, Excellent and Outstanding. The assessment is carried out by independent BREEAM assessors who ensure that the buildings fulfil or exceed certain standards. However, the focus is on environmental sustainability, even though social aspects have been given greater consideration since the product update in 2008.

Further insights into the world of property